Be it due to lack of technology or lack of Dr. Money's interest in hormones and the affect they have on determining sex it can be regarded that he crossed certain ethical boundaries that should not have been breached. As you can recall (if you read the chapter) the "differentiation of external genitals and several aspects of brain development depend mainly on the level of testosterone." (Kalat, et al, 2009) If this knowledge had been known Dr. Money's theory on rearing could have had a strong opposition. Yet no such information from my knowledge was available when Mr. Reimer's parents were looking for a solution to his situation. We come to understand as this section progress' that childhood behavior is impacted by socialization but not just that alone. In a study by Alexander, Wilcox and Woods in 2009 infants (of both sexes) were placed in front of an array of toys ranging from either feminine (dolls, tea sets), masculine (toy trucks) or neutral toys (crayons, etc). The infants used in this study ranged from ages of 3 to 8 months old. The researchers were able to gauge preference by the amount of times each sex looked at either the female, masculine or neutral toys. The end result being that the girl infants looked more at the dolls whereas the boys looked at the trucks or neutral objects. Now that being said it is easier to understand why Brenda had such a great deal of inner turmoil when it came to dealing with being a girl.
There are a few more videos in regard to David Reimer and his life; which I encourage you to watch. Learning about his story not only appalled me but brought to my awareness what gender confusion could be like and I hope that you will think twice before judging someone because they might look like a certain sex but adopt lifestyles of the other.
I am shocked! I believe Dr. Money took advantage of the situation that went wrong, and David Reimer's parents did a bad decision in allowing their children become a guinea pigs in Dr. Money's experiment. I can't imagine how traumatized the children were after being forced to get nude, just so Dr. Money could get his hypothesis right! While watching these videos a mixture of emotions ran through my head. I was angry, sad, disturbed, and upset at how obsessed a doctor can become and the things he is willing to do just to prove his hypothesis correct. I think what even got me more angry is how David's parents didn't find out what was going on!
ReplyDeleteI remember watching these videos a few weeks ago and thinking, what a terrible situation to be in, even for the parents. It was definitely wrong in my opinion to treat humans as we want just because we don't like the idea of what they truly are. The videos were definitely eye openers on judgment and so was this whole chapter.
ReplyDelete